Backpage.com’s Adult Section: Freedom of the Press? or Profiting from Sex Trafficking?

Posted: November 4, 2011 in backpage.com, forced prostitution, freedom of the press, human trafficking, sex trafficking
Tags: , , , ,

Village Voice Media has an online ad section called Backpage.com.  One of the sections is “Adult”, and critics say that occasionally it’s used by sex traffickers to sell sex with minors.  Backpage.com defends the practice as free press.  They use the analogy that just because people sometimes send illegal material through the mail, we don’t shut down the post office.  They also claim that if they don’t sell the ads, someone else will.  Critics want them to either remove the adult section altogether, or require identification and photos for all Adult ads to prevent sexual abuse of minors.   It’s a similar situation to Craigslist, which last year shut down its paid adult services section after persistent pressure from a variety of sources.

The NY Times has an article on the subject titled Fighting Over Online Sex Ads.

Should advertisers be free to accept ads, when they don’t control the content, and when there is a significant risk that the ads may be used to sell sex with minors?

Is this a strictly legal issue, implicating freedom of the press?

Is this a moral issue where a business needs to respond to public pressure and proactively protect minors from being sexually trafficked?

What do you think of the analogies that Backpage is using?  Is there a similarity between someone using the Adult section of Backpage.com to advertise prostitution which turns out to be sex trafficking of a minor, and someone using the postal service to transport illegal material from one person to another?  Does it make a difference to you that the advertising is broadcast by an unidentified poster to all readers, while the post office is transporting material from one identifiable source to a specific addressee? 

What about the argument that if Backpage.com shuts down its Adult section, those people will advertise somewhere else?  For instance, when Craigslist shut down its paid adult services section, how many of those customers went to Backpage.com, and other such alternatives?  Is this similar to a community attempting to move an adult bookstore or theater out of a high traffic downtown neighborhood? 

What about the critics?  Is their request to have Backpage.com require positive ID of those advertising in the Adult section reasonable?  Would it help the situation? 

Do they have a right to have Backpage.com shut down the Adult section on moral grounds?  Is the possibility that minors might be trafficked sufficient to warrant shutting down the Adult section? 

What arguments are most persuasive to you?  Please add your thoughts and comments.

Advertisements
Comments
  1. If your tween is into paint-ball you can take everyone to play
    paint-ball. You make different challenges like scavenger hunts, food challenges, mazes and races.
    Every Halloween party that people remember later in the year by
    saying things like “Do you remember so-and-so’s Halloween party last year.

  2. You should give this video (on one organization’s efforts to help victims of sex trafficking in Israel) a view, it’s pretty powerful stuff.

    • Carl says:

      Christopher,

      Thanks for your suggestion of the video. I watched it and feel it’s well done, highlighting what Operation Blessing is doing in Israel. This kind of message is an important one to get out, and I hope others will view it too. Do you have any connection to Operation Blessing? How did you hear about the organization or find the video?

      -Carl

  3. Becky says:

    Canada has been identified as both a transit and a destination point for human trafficking, and Vancouver (located in British Columbia) has been singled out by the U.S. State Department as a port of major concern. However, British Columbia’s Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General, Shirley Bond, drastically cut funding to the province’s Office To Combat Trafficking In Persons. This occurred in July of 2011, and resulted in the termination of the Executive Director, Robin Pike. There is no longer an Executive Director position, and as it stands there are only 2 employees working in this office, period. Please join me in telling my province’s Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General and Premier, that this is unacceptable. http://www.change.org/petitions/minister-of-public-safety-and-solicitor-general-increase-octips-budget-to-750000-annually-and-rehire-robin-pike

    • Carl says:

      Hi Becky,

      Thanks for your comment and sorry for the slow reply. I appreciate you informing me about this situation in BC. It’s amazing that we live in Canada and the US where there are so many law enforcement and other resources, but we can’t allocate more money toward stopping slavery within our borders.

      -Carl

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s